Author: Susan Dennard
Date of Publication: 5th January 2016
Synopsis: Safi and Iseult, Threadsisters and long time friends, become embroiled in a game of cat and mouse. They are chased by a myriad of people, all who want to get hold of Safi’s unique power to tell when people speak the truth…
Hmm. Apologies in advance if this review seems rambling or nonsensical. If it is, it’s because I’m really note sure how I feel about this book.
Truthwitch was massively hyped when it first came out a year ago. It was bought for me as a present last Christmas and it kept lingering around the top of my TBR pile. Finally, when Windwitch was on the precipice of being released, I decided it was time to commit and read this. Perhaps it was the hype that did it, or the waiting, or a mixture of the two. Either way, I found myself non-plussed for the first 150 pages. There were moments of action, adventure and fun but mostly I just felt a little…bored.
I can’t really say why this is. I liked Safi and Iseult, I really liked Aeduan and the magic within the world was interesting to me. However everything seemed a little flat, a little forced. It wasn’t until I was about a third of the way in that I felt Dennard really fell into her storytelling – the characters becoming more rich and the weaving of their stories becoming more substantial. By the end I was becoming invested in the stories, but it had taken too long for me to get there.
Whilst I think the characterisation is good overall Safi occasionally strayed into the realms of the ridiculous for me, and Merik was only occasionally enjoyable to read. I must preferred the Iseult and Aduean chapters. There were times at which the plot felt muddy because there were so many characters interests to be served – ensemble casts are never easy and Dennard does occasionally struggle with balancing a plot with a multitude of characters.
By the end I was set on reading the sequel, which is all the Dennard’s talent at pulling me back in. Usually you will see a writer improve over the course of a series – rarely do you see such improvement over the course of a single book. I’m looking forward to seeing what comes next, but beware the hype.
Author(s): Jay Kristoff and Amie Kaufman
Date of Publication: 20th October 2015
Synopsis: When their world is invaded by a corporation intent on destroying any evidence of their involvement, Kady and Ezra find themselves part of a fleet of survivors battling to escape – and to make things harder they just broke up that morning.
Usually when there’s this kind of hype about a book I treat it with extreme caution. I don’t know why my bookish-senses start tingling, perhaps I’m the skeptical sort. However it got to a point at which I couldn’t put this off any longer. And boy was deciding to finally read this the best decision I’ve made in a while because this is stunning
Firstly you have to read this in paperback / hardback. There is such a rich form of storytelling taking place, which is so heavily linked to the way the book is formatted – I can’t believe you would get the same out of it via e-reader. You’re led through the book via messaging between characters, transcripts of conversations, written accounts of CCTV and other various storytelling methods. It’s ingenious and works perfectly with the setting and subject matter. Everything feels exciting and imminent – the story races along and the authors easily overcome the challenge of making their audience connect with their characters. They don’t shy away from darkness and there are many grim and terrible moments to be found within. However they’re never gratuitous, always working with the story to make the reading feel all the more real.
I loved the plot – simple and complex at the same time. Kady and Ezra, the main characters, are well developed and great doorways both into the vaster world of the series and of the present action. I found myself rooting for them almost from the beginning – something which surprised me, as I usually don’t go for pre-existing relationships, instead preferring to see characters form bonds from nothing throughout a book / series. Kady especially really stood out as a great, strong female protagonist. She was a lot of fun to read about, even in the bleakest and most hopeless of situations.
For sci-fi fans this is a must read – I’ve already ordered the sequel!
Author: Stephanie Garber
Date of Publication: 26th January 2017
Synopsis: Sisters escape their abusive and tyrannial Father and fall into the renowned performance that is Caraval. A race against other competitors ensues; with heavy doses of love, magic and intrigue.
This book was sent to me in exchange for an honest review. My thanks go to Stephanie Garber, Hodder and Stoughton and Netgalley for the opportunity.
…”real or not, she must find Tella before the game is over, and her sister disappears forever . . .”
There you have it; real or not. This is for me the central theme of Caraval. Whilst this book is many other things; a tale of the bond between sisters, an account of familial abuse, a love story….despite everything else, the author is always circling around this difficult to answer question. It is what makes this so captivating to me as a reader and it is what pulled me by the hand right up until the final pages. I was, from the very first, completely willing to take part in the performance laid before me.
I have read books before where plot twists spiral around one another, linked so densely and so tightly sequenced as to confuse and frustrate. However here Stephanie Garber weaves with a deftness which leaves no doubt as to her skill as a writer. Even as shock after horror after revelation shower down upon the characters, I was never overwhelmed because it is all part of the game – and that is where Garber has struck gold. She has created a plot within which every whim and desire can be done and undone. Nothing, once decided on, is set in stone. By doing this there is no expected – leaving me as invested in the outcome as Scarlett herself – and as unsure as to where we’re headed next.
Garber has also created some wonderful characters; both Scarlett and Donatella appealed to me from the start. Scarlett is self-sacrificing, sensible and almost completely, miserably accepting of her lot in life. Donatella however, just as self-sacrificing in a less obvious way, is still full of fight and fury against their situation. The contrast really heightens Scarlett’s journey throughout the performance (note performance, rather than competition, is how I view the central conceit)- and Garber gives her the perfect partner to play against in Julian.
I feel that romance is difficult in YA Fantasy – everything has been done before. Garber earns my unending thanks for not including a love triangle here (my bane) and instead uses the time to build something between Julian and Scarlet which is bathed in all the secrecy and costume of Caraval, yet at the same time has some truly shining moments of honesty (or are they?!). There are layers upon layers to Julian’s character and he is fascinating to read – especially in conjunction with the endless veneers of plot constantly concealing his true intentions and feelings.
My only slight criticism would be that I felt there could easily have been another fifty pages added. The fast pacing occasionally stumbled in its haste, meaning important scenes felt slightly rushed in the need to not linger too long and instead move straight to the next. Sometimes a little lingering gives not only the reader time to breathe but also the characters themselves.
Why should you pick up Caraval? If you’re not interested in rich description, full and compelling characters, a beautiful world, a dark and complex plot and both romantic love and sisterly adoration then you probably shouldn’t. However you would be missing out. This is a fantastical and wholly vibrant debut which kept me guessing until the very end and made me itch to re-enter the Caraval and relive the race for the winner’s wish.
Author: Alexandra Bracken
Date of Publication: 3rd January 2017
Synopsis: The sequel to Passenger sees Etta and Nicholas separated; searching through time for both each other and the infamous Astrolabe.
This book was provided in exchange for an honest review. My thanks go to Alexandra Bracken, Hatchette Children’s Group and Netgalley for the opportunity
When I read Passenger about a year ago I was left with love hate feelings for the book. At times the pace pulled me along, breathless and excited to see what happened next. Yet also there were dense periods of unnecessary introspection and exposition which weighed down those shining moments; ultimately tarnishing them. I found the lead characters dull in comparison to the supporting ones; always aching for more of the latter and instead being weighed down by an abundance of the former.
Unfortunately I found Wayfarer much the same – with the caveat that pacing is certainly improved here and there is lot more from the characters I loved. Alexandra Bracken did a lot of laying down of framework in the first instalment, which left Wayfarer with many, many strands to tie up. Ultimately that wasn’t a bad thing, because it kept things interesting. Yet somehow, despite everything that was going on, Wayfarer still felt far, far too long.
Firstly a potentially unpopular opinion – I liked Etta and Nicholas being separated. I found their journeys with Julian and the Thorns and Sophia and Li Minh (respectively) far more interesting than their shared adventures in the first book. Perhaps this is because the side characters are easily as compelling, if not more so, as our heroes. I know the central romance is supposed to be a massive part of the book, but it never really worked for me. Therefore the less of it, in my eyes, the better (in fact, let’s swap it for Sophia and Li Minh!).
One plot point I couldn’t get enough of was Etta and her Father. Without spoiling who that is, or their role in the book, I found every single scene they were in together to be raw and heartbreaking whilst at the same time wholly joy filled. Bracken wrote something incredibly real when she wrote that relationship and it was probably the thing that will sit with me longest in this duology.
In contrast to the good, there was the not so good. Ironwood didn’t feel like he was given the time to really dominate the lives of the characters; always a hissed name and a changing landscape as opposed to an actual presence. Whilst his actions were terrifying, I wanted more than just consequences of his actions – I wanted a character I could loathe. The other big bad, to be frank, I found faintly ridiculous, as menacing as it was supposed to be. If there had been more build up I would definitely have bought into them but, as it stands, I just didn’t see the point of their inclusion.
Wayfarer is definitely an improvement on its predecessor but for me there was always a slight sense of wistful disappointment for what might have been. Bracken is undoubtedly a talented writer. She is also to be applauded for including both a non-white male lead and non-het supporting characters into a genre sorely lacking both. However I found her plots in this case are too multitudinous; making a strong concept unnecessarily drawn out and messy. A sharper edit and this duology would be amazing. As it stands I’m still in that same love-hate place I was twelve months ago.